ARC Review Tracking: Making Sure Reviews Actually Get Posted
Distributing ARCs is easy. Getting readers to actually post reviews is the hard part. Here's how to track and improve completion.
2-Minute Summary
Review tracking means knowing exactly which ARC readers have posted their review, which haven't, and following up appropriately. Most ARC programs see a 30-50% review rate — tracking helps you improve that number over time.
Why It Matters
Without tracking, authors either over-email their entire ARC list (annoying readers who already reviewed) or under-follow-up (missing reviews from readers who simply forgot). Accurate tracking fixes both problems.
Benefits of Tracking Reviews
- More accurate, less annoying follow-up communication
- Visibility into your actual review completion rate
- Data to identify and prioritize your most reliable readers
Step-by-Step: Tracking Process
- Ask readers to submit their review link — a simple form after they post, rather than you searching for it
- Mark status as reviewed once confirmed — keep your list current
- Send one follow-up reminder — about a week before launch, to readers still marked unreviewed
- Accept that not everyone will review — 100% completion is not realistic; 30-50% is a healthy range
- Review your rate after each launch — compare across books to see if your recruiting or follow-up process is improving
Common Mistakes
- Manually searching Amazon and Goodreads for reviews instead of asking readers to submit links
- Sending multiple redundant reminders to readers who already reviewed
- Expecting a 100% review rate and feeling discouraged by normal 30-50% completion
Examples
An author who asks readers to submit their review link directly, rather than manually checking each platform, cuts their tracking time from hours to minutes per launch — and can send precise, single follow-ups to only the readers who still need one.
Frequently Asked Questions
See below.
How AuthorLoft Helps
AuthorLoft's ARC management tools let readers submit review confirmations directly, so your review-status list stays accurate without manual searching.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a normal ARC review completion rate?
Most ARC programs see 30-50% of readers actually post a review. 100% completion is not realistic to expect.
How should I follow up with ARC readers who haven't reviewed?
Send one gentle reminder about a week before launch, targeted only at readers still marked as not yet reviewed.
Should I manually search for ARC reviews online?
It's more efficient to ask readers to submit their review link directly through a simple form rather than manually searching each retailer or platform.
· Track reviews without the manual work·
AuthorLoft lets ARC readers submit review confirmations directly, keeping your list accurate automatically.
Keep 100 % of every sale and own every reader relationship — no middleman.
Get Started Free